The rules have been compromiced now and its not as firm as it looks, although this is our rules.
Our problem is not many ppl are online at once, and thats why two or more officers, including leader must determin if the person is to get warning or be dispatched..
The rules is made to maintain a surtain structure just to try to make guild work optimal, it might sound strict but im sure its not..and yes we do meet up to make decition about promotion, or dispatchment..earlyer we also had guild meetings..but it didnt work out.
For officers to get demoted as this rule contains its either to loong periode off, this periode is usefull to test out new candidates for officer position, or missbehaving..this can result in direct demoting..
As main rules in guild sayes in the beginning, we do take pride in not kicking ppl for no reason, and ppl are good at behaving in this guild.
In this guild i have been forced to kick only one person due to missbehaving in entire guild history, this sayes more about this than anything else..and the guild is from 2005.
But i take your advice seriously, and will consider maybe a poll in forum, for ppl to cast wote on next officers candidates..